Search

 

Disclaimer 

In October 2012 our shortened URL (www.thewillandthewallet.org) expired and was purchased by spammers before we were able to reclaim it. Part of their misuse includes redirecting this URL to an imposter site that has advertisements posted in the comment boxes. Stimson is working to take down that site and reclaim the domain name. In the interim, please update your bookmarks accordingly to www.thewillandthewallet.squarespace.com. Thank you all for your patience as we work through this issue.

Picture This

(Gallup)

Wordwise

“Modest reforms to pay and compensation will improve readiness and modernization. It will help keep our all-volunteer force sustainable and strong. Keeping faith also means investing sufficient resources so that we can uphold our sacred obligations to defend the nation and to send our sons and daughters to war with only the best training, leadership and equipment. We can’t shrink from our obligations to one another. The stakes are too high.”

Gen. Martin E. Dempsey

« Top Heavy | Main | The Builddown »
Monday
Dec052011

Even the Fanciest

One of the Air Force’s stealth drones has crashed in Iran.  We’ll leave to others the intelligence and diplomatic implications of that.  But such a crash does have budgetary implications.  

The Air Force has increasingly noted that current unmanned drones—specifically Predators and Reapers—can’t survive in denied airspace.  As the Vice Chief of Staff of the Air Force said last November in arguing for new procurement programs:

One has to remember that the current ISR fleet … is absolutely a permissive fleet.  The Predator, the Reaper, the Global Hawk will not fly in contested [airspace] and will certainly not fly in denied airspace.

But the stealth drone’s crash shows even the fanciest drones will still have problems in all kinds of airspace, regardless of whether it was shot down or crashed for some other reason. (So do manned aircraft for that matter).  Our recent report on procurement suggested why this dynamic has budgetary implications: the Air Force has had a predilection for pursuing high-end systems.  The Reaper itself is a fancier version of the Predator. 

We don’t mean to second-guess the Air Force’s operational trade-offs between quality and quantity.  Those trade-offs are real.  But those operational trade-offs also have budgetary trade-offs.  Even in flush times for the defense budget—like the last decade, resources are still finite and prevent us from getting as much quantity as we may like.   If we romanticize what high-end capabilities can do operationally (like never crash), we can cloud our decisions on budgetary trade-offs.  Those trade-offs will only be exacerbated in the new era of budgetary austerity.